An Economic Analysis Comparing School-based Programs
Commentary authors
Susan H. Babey
Shinyi Wu
Deborah Cohen
Summary

The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services advises 60 minutes of daily physical activity for youth, but few meet these guidelines, especially during school hours. To address this, a study evaluated various school-based strategies, highlighting extending the school day with mandatory PE and introducing short, 10-minute physical activity breaks during classes as the most cost-effective options at $264 and less than $5 per child annually, respectively. Despite the higher cost of after-school programs at $2867 per child yearly, they offer additional benefits like childcare. Program costs were primarily influenced by duration and teacher-to-student ratio, yet all approaches showed similar effectiveness. The study emphasized the cost-effective integration of short, in-class activity breaks as an affordable and feasible means to combat youth sedentary behavior, promoting better physical activity levels during the school day.

Summer Bridge Programs and Degree Completion
Commentary authors
Daniel Douglas
Paul Attewell
Summary

College graduation rates in the U.S. are low, prompting interest in solutions like "summer bridge" programs, where students take pre-academic year courses. Some attribute low graduation rates to poor academic readiness and slow academic progress. Research shows higher course-taking rates improve graduation chances. Summer bridge programs address these concerns. Analyzing nationally representative college data and a large university system, a new study uses propensity score matching to assess these programs' effects. Nationally, bridge program attendees at community colleges and less-selective four-year colleges were 10% more likely to graduate within six years. Effects were more pronounced among black/Hispanic, first-gen, and lower GPA students. University data revealed immediate benefits—better retention, course performance, and credit completion. While bridge programs aid graduation, institutions should evaluate existing programs before expanding, considering mixed findings elsewhere. Addressing specific academic barriers, like remedial sequences, enhances immediate benefits, showcasing bridge programs as part of a larger strategy to boost graduation rates.

Commentary author
Terri Sabol
Summary

Head Start, the primary federally-funded preschool program in the U.S., serving over 1 million children yearly, emphasizes not just child education but also parental engagement and growth. However, research traditionally prioritizes children’s outcomes over parents’. Leveraging the Head Start Impact Study (HSIS)—the comprehensive evaluation and reporting program initiated in 1998—a new study explores if children’s participation in Head Start affects parents' education and employment. HSIS found short-term benefits for kids, fading by third grade, stirring doubts about long-term effectiveness. Research analysis, considering the family as a unit, discovered that parents of 3-year-olds in Head Start showed greater educational advancements by kindergarten compared to the control group. This effect was particularly pronounced for parents with some college but no degree and African American parents. These findings highlight Head Start's potential to support parents' educational pursuits, offering quality childcare, support networks, and pathways to higher education. This underscores how early education programs like Head Start can bolster parental growth alongside children's development, potentially influencing other similar programs.

Commentary author
Caitlin Farrell
Summary

Educators face growing pressure to utilize data for informed decision-making, yet the research supporting this movement remains underdeveloped. A recent Educational Administration Quarterly article delves into organizational factors influencing data use, drawing from four California school systems. Across traditional districts and charter management organizations (CMOs), state and federal accountability systems heavily shape data use. These systems prioritize data from state assessments and benchmark exams, crucial for program improvement and attracting families in charter schools. Organizational conditions, like decision-making structures, financial resources, and regulatory environments, impact resource allocation for data use. While financial constraints universally limit efforts, CMOs’ decentralized structures enable investments in human capital and technology. These findings highlight tensions arising from diverse accountability demands and propose revisiting metrics underpinning success. They also suggest avenues for sharing best practices, such as districts aiding teacher support while CMOs demonstrate advanced data management systems. Policymakers can leverage these insights to navigate accountability complexities and foster cross-system learning.

November 17, 2014 | EdSource

More than half of California voters said they knew nothing or very little about the state’s new Common Core standards for English language arts and math, according to a newly released report by the Policy Analysis for California Education/USC Rossier...

Evidence From College Remediation
Commentary author
Judith Scott-Clayton
Summary

Current approaches to determining college readiness often rely on standardized placement tests in math and English, leading to nearly half of community college students being placed into remedial classes. However, research suggests that a significant portion of students placed in remediation based on these tests could succeed in college-level courses. By examining high school performance alongside placement test scores, studies have shown that using high school achievement data could significantly reduce placement errors and improve success rates in college-level courses. Integrating high school grades in placement decisions has demonstrated remarkable success, with programs like Long Beach City College’s Promise Pathways quadrupling placement rates in college English courses and significantly increasing completion rates in both English and math. These findings have influenced California’s community college system, prompting a shift toward multiple measures for placement, offering a more equitable and effective approach to remedial education. The adoption of a nuanced placement system utilizing various academic measures shows promise for improving outcomes and fairness in remediation.

November 7, 2014 | EdSource

A new study that examines the implementation of California’s Local Control Funding Formula revealed that district leaders welcome a need-based local funding model but that they were hindered by a lack of time, information, skills and resources. The report, “Toward...

Children’s Early Grade Retention After Paternal Incarceration
Commentary author
Kristin Turney
Summary

Around 2.6 million American children have a parent currently or formerly incarcerated, constituting nearly 10% of those under 18. While the impact of parental incarceration on generations has gained attention, little research explores its effects on elementary-aged children’s education. Using Fragile Families and Child Wellbeing Study data, our research unveils a link between paternal incarceration during ages one to five and increased likelihood of grade retention in kindergarten to third grade. Notably, this isn’t tied to test scores or behavior issues; rather, teachers’ perceptions of academic ability seem pivotal. This highlights teachers’ role in children's lives post-paternal incarceration. It also underscores the interconnectedness of family, education, and the penal system. Educators could benefit from training to support kids of incarcerated fathers, while the penal system should recognize its impact on children’s education. Holistic policies acknowledging these links are crucial to break the cycle of inequality across generations.

October 28, 2014 | Education Week

Now, this is different: The California legislature passed a law, and people actually like it. They are trying hard to implement the spirit of the state’s new finance formula rather than trivialize it with minimum compliance behavior. Such is the...

Commentary author
Fiona Hollands
Summary

Education policies often focus on evaluating the effectiveness of interventions without considering their costs. This oversight limits policymakers’ ability to make informed decisions about resource allocation. Understanding intervention costs in relation to their effectiveness is crucial for efficient policymaking. For instance, reducing high school dropout rates, a national priority, could alleviate substantial economic burdens, yet education budgets are limited. Researchers conducted cost-effectiveness analyses on five dropout prevention programs, finding considerable variations in costs and effectiveness. Remedial programs aimed at dropouts were notably more expensive per additional graduate compared to preventative programs, which targeted at-risk students still in school. These findings emphasize the need for cost-effectiveness assessments in educational program evaluations to guide policymaking effectively. Without such analyses, research evidence alone may not provide policymakers with a comprehensive view for decision-making, potentially leading to inefficient resource allocation.

October 27, 2014 | USC Rossier News
Will the Vergara decision make a difference for students? That is the question experts hope to answer this Wednesday, Oct. 29, when they gather for a public forum on the subject at UC Berkeley’s Graduate School of Education. Katharine Strunk, Associate Professor of Education and Policy at USC Rossier, joins other panelists at the event co-sponsored by UC Berkeley’s Graduate School of Education and PACE, Policy Analysis for California Education.
October 21, 2014 | EdSource

With a nod to California, a new report suggests overhauling how school and student success is measured in the United States. The report, by the Stanford Center for Opportunity Policy in Education and the National Center for Innovation in Education...